Micropore Tape vs Transpore? Adhesive Medical Solutions

In the realm of medical care, the selection of adhesive tapes plays a crucial role in ensuring optimal patient comfort, wound care, and treatment efficacy. Micropore and Transpore tapes emerge as prominent contenders, each offering unique properties and applications in clinical settings. As healthcare professionals strive to make informed decisions regarding tape selection, understanding the distinctive characteristics and advantages of Micropore versus Transpore tape becomes imperative. 

In this article, we embark on a comprehensive exploration of these adhesive medical solutions. By delving into this comparative analysis, we aim to equip healthcare practitioners with the knowledge necessary to enhance patient care standards and navigate the complexities of adhesive medical solutions effectively.

3M Micropore Tape

 

While there are many imposters, there is only one tape that can go by the name Micropore. It’s the one manufactured by the fine folks at 3M.

Some people prefer to call it “paper tape,” but that’s like calling Kleenex facial tissue. It’s a misnomer. The actual paper part of Micropore is made from rayon, like the stuff in your stretchy yoga pants, but it feels more like paper than yoga pant fabric.

There are many types of paper tape, none of which present the properties in Micropore. Like it’s parent-product, paper, as in the stuff you’d use to write a note, Micropore tape is porous.

This porous quality allows it to “breathe” in the conventional sense of the word, but also allows for moisture to pass through. It’s like sticking the paper to your skin.

As such, Micropore tape such as the 3M Micropore Surgical Tape is as flexible as paper, meaning not much. This limitation makes it hard to use on parts of the body that need to flex and extend much. We’ll get to alternatives for those situations in just a minute.

Another aspect of Micropore tape separating it from traditional paper is that it’s adhesive. The sticky side of Micropore tape adheres to the skin without leaving residue and without causing pain when removed.

The way it sticks then peels off with ease is a big part of the charm, a voodoo quality by most accounts. Not only will it stick to skin, but to plastic, glass, and other tapes.

What is 3M Micropore tape used for?

Most common uses for Micropore tape involve dressing wounds or holding a medical tubing in place.

Because Micropore breathes as well as it adheres, it’s perfect for these cases. It adheres well to moist skin, and not too firmly to dry skin, but sticks long enough to both to make it versatile provided the stress on the tape isn’t too much.

That’s where some of Micropore’s more-capable siblings take over. We’ll come back to a few of them in a second.

In most cases where a wound or tube needs adhering, the benchmark is Micropore until it proves incapable of the task.

One of the reasons this try-first approach to Micropore tape is the user-friendly nature of the product. It comes off about as easy as it goes on, unlike the aforementioned duct tape. That stuff sticks like old medical tape.

Anyone who’s ever had gummy tape from an old first aid kit peeled off a healing wound can attest: the less pulling the better.

3M ranks their tapes on a scale of skin trauma. No surprise that Micropore lands in the top two of the more favourable end, meaning less chance of trauma.

All that aside, the bigger influencer affecting heavy usage of Micropore comes down to expense. Micropore remains one of the most affordable 3M adhesive tapes.

Why use something more costly when a cheaper solution does the job? Especially if it does the job better.

 

Micropore tape for scars

When used correctly, it can contribute to the flattening and softening of scars over time by providing consistent pressure and hydration to the affected area. Based on our professional knowledge it's crucial to begin with clean, dry skin before applying Micropore tape for scars. Smoothly apply the tape directly over the scar, ensuring no wrinkles or bubbles. Wear it consistently for several hours each day while monitoring skin sensitivity. Understand that visible results may take time, requiring patience. For enhanced effectiveness, consider combining Micropore tape with other scar treatments.

If you try to use Micropore tape to close a serious wound — the definition of which is beyond this blog to define —  you could risk serious harm beyond an impoverished recovery.

 

Micropore tape vs Transpore

In the 3M lineup, the closest substitute for Micropore is their Transpore tape. There are actually two versions of this tape, a wound-dressing version which acts more like Micropore, and a surgical version. The latter is more plastic to the touch.

Similar to Micropore, the dressing version of Transpore uses rayon in the backing, but in this case, they’ve blended it with polyester, leveraging the best of both fibres to make a hybrid.

This makes it slightly more costly but keeps the cost the same neighbourhood as Micropore tape.

Transpore too works well on dry or wet skin, and is even easier to handle than Micropore, with bare hands or gloves as may be necessary. You tear it bidirectionally to better accommodate the needs of a given wound.

The surgical version of Transpore is only polyethylene, clear, and best for securing heavy tubes in place.

Where both Transpore tapes differ, especially the surgical version is with removal. They both stick so well if the wound is sensitive there could be more trauma when removing them.

 

Micropore vs Durapore

Stepping up the cost a little more, one finds 3M's Durapore. Compared to the paper quality of Micropore, and the plastic tape nature of Transpore, Durapore tape is silky. It’s not actually made from silk, though.

It’s a strong, tafetta-backed tape, one that also tears bidirectionally. It would be overkill on most wounds as a dressing but works wonders for securing heavy tubes and even holding splints in place.

Coming off the skin, however, Durapore will pull more than Micropore so using it would not be wise unless necessary, especially if it will be directly applied to skin that is dry. It’s also not so effective adhering to moist skin.

For the added cost and adhesion, unless it’s necessary most will try to get away with Micropore before pulling out this tough tape. Once you go above this 3M option, the technical aspects of the option only add to the cost and specificity of use.

Author: Steven John Cumper, B.App.SC. (Osteo.), M.Ost., is a businessman with a strong foundation in biomedical science and osteopathic medicine, who founded and led Medshop to international success, culminating in its acquisition by the Bunzl Group in September 2021, where he continues to serve as Managing Director (Medshop Group).